| Platinum | Fiesta JalapeñOs |
| Gold | Guadalajara Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Cazador |
| Bronze | Abelardo's Mexican Fresh |
| Top Pick | Amigos Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Cancun Grill & Cantina - Ankeny |
| Top Pick | El Molcajete |
| Top Pick | Hidalgo Mexican Bar and Grill Ankeny |
| Top Pick | Malo |
| Top Pick | Mojito's Mexican Restaurant |