| Platinum | Nonna's Ankeny |
| Gold | Portofino's Italian Restaurant & Pizza |
| Silver | Wig & Pen Pizza Pub |
| Bronze | Simons |
| Top Pick | Baratta's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Biaggi's |
| Top Pick | Chucks Italian American Restaurant |
| Top Pick | OPA! Italian & Greek |
| Top Pick | Sonny's Pizza Bistro |
| Top Pick | Tumea & Sons Restaurant |