| Platinum | The Cookie Jar |
| Gold | ButterSweet Custom Bakery |
| Silver | Home Slice Handmade Pies |
| Bronze | Main Street Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Always Baked-Sweets and Treats |
| Top Pick | Gladdies |
| Top Pick | Pie Five Pizza CLOSED |
| Top Pick | The Outside Scoop |
| Top Pick | Uptown Confections & Curiosities |
| Top Pick | Uptown Dairy |
| TJ's Bagel Basket |